Current:Home > InvestAlito rejects Democrats' demands to step aside from upcoming Supreme Court case-Angel Dreamer Wealth Society D1 Reviews & Insights
Alito rejects Democrats' demands to step aside from upcoming Supreme Court case
View Date:2024-12-24 00:47:42
Washington — Justice Samuel Alito on Friday rejected demands from Senate Democrats that he step aside from an upcoming Supreme Court case because of his interactions with one of the lawyers involved, in a fresh demonstration of tensions over ethical issues.
Alito attached an unusual statement to an otherwise routine list of orders from the court. "There is no valid reason for my recusal in this case," Alito wrote in a four-page statement.
Democrats on the Senate Judiciary Committee have been highly critical of Alito and the rest of the court for failing to adopt an ethics code, following reports of undisclosed paid trips taken by Justice Clarence Thomas and, on one occasion, by Alito. The committee approved an ethics code for the court on a party-line vote, though it is unlikely to become law.
Last month, Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman Dick Durbin of Illinois and other Democrats on the committee sent a letter to Chief Justice John Roberts calling on Alito to not participate in a tax case that will be argued in the late fall.
The Democrats complained that Alito himself had cast doubt on his ability to judge the case fairly because he sat for four hours of Wall Street Journal opinion page interviews with an editor at the newspaper and David Rivkin, one of the lawyers for the couple suing over a tax bill. Rivkin also represents Leonard Leo, the onetime leader of the conservative legal group The Federalist Society, in his dealings with the Senate Democrats, who want details of Leo's involvement with the justices. Leo helped arrange a private trip Alito took to Alaska in 2008.
In the second of two articles the interviews produced, Alito said Congress lacked the authority to impose a code of ethics on the Supreme Court.
The statement was issued a day after Justice Brett Kavanaugh said he is hopeful, without offering specifics, that the court will soon take "concrete steps" to address ethical concerns.
Justices typically do not respond to calls for their recusals, except in the rare instances in which they are made by parties to the case. But Alito said he was responding because of the attention the issue already has received.
He noted that many of his former and current colleagues have given interviews to reporters and then taken part in cases involving the reporters' media outlets.
Describing the Democrats' argument as "unsound," Alito went on to write, "When Mr. Rivkin participated in the interviews and co-authored the articles, he did so as a journalist, not an advocate. The case in which he is involved was never mentioned; nor did we discuss any issue in that case either directly or indirectly. His involvement in the case was disclosed in the second article, and therefore readers could take that into account."
- In:
- Supreme Court of the United States
- Clarence Thomas
- Politics
veryGood! (47)
Related
- Spurs coach Gregg Popovich had a stroke earlier this month, is expected to make full recovery
- This summer's crazy weather just can't stop, won't stop Americans from having fun
- Leonard Bernstein's children defend Bradley Cooper following criticism over prosthetic nose
- Netflix's Selling the OC Season 2 Premiere Date Revealed
- A Pipeline Runs Through It
- NBA releases its schedule for the coming season, with an eye on player rest and travel
- District attorney drops at least 30 cases that involved officers charged in death of Tyre Nichols
- Britney Spears' net worth: Her earnings, real estate and divorces
- Judge extends the time to indict the driver accused of killing Johnny Gaudreau and his brother
- Colts star Jonathan Taylor 'excused' from training camp due to 'personal matter'
Ranking
- Justine Bateman feels like she can breathe again in 'new era' after Trump win
- Britney Spears' net worth: Her earnings, real estate and divorces
- Dominican investigation of Rays’ Wander Franco is being led by gender violence and minors division
- Sean and Leigh Anne Tuohy to End Michael Oher Conservatorship Amid Lawsuit
- The 15 quickest pickup trucks MotorTrend has ever tested
- Biden will use Camp David backdrop hoping to broker a breakthrough in Japan-South Korea relations
- North Carolina Republicans finalize passage of an elections bill that could withstand a veto
- Bradley Cooper, 'Maestro' and Hollywood's 'Jewface' problem
Recommendation
-
California man allegedly shot couple and set their bodies, Teslas on fire in desert
-
New Jersey shutters 27 Boston Market restaurants over unpaid wages, related worker issues
-
Mississippi judge declares mistrial in case of 2 white men charged in attack on Black FedEx driver
-
Dominican investigation of Rays’ Wander Franco is being led by gender violence and minors division
-
He failed as a service dog. But that didn't stop him from joining the police force
-
USC study reveals Hollywood studios are still lagging when it comes to inclusivity
-
Bills’ Damar Hamlin has little more to prove in completing comeback, coach Sean McDermott says
-
2 American tourists found sleeping atop Eiffel Tower in Paris